Decisions decisions... CSS or CSA?

Greetings all. My hubby and I went to Couples Negril in Nov 2004. It was a-m-a-z-i-n-g and one of the best vacations of our lives. We are planning to come back to Jamaica in November of this year but we are having a hard time deciding which resort to choose.

He would like to try a different resort this time. We are trying to decide between CSS and CSA. What are the pros and cons?? As a couple that loved CN... which one of the two would provide the most awesome experience?? We like to lay around on the beach, do a couple excursions, and have really good food. We are not looking for too much wild nightlife; just a relaxing time to reconnect with each other whilst away from our 3 wonderful kiddos.

Thanks all!