For one, a lot of the devotion you will find comes from the first place a person has stayed. For many, their first resort is their favorite. Because no matter what, they can't help but compare all subsequent resorts to that first one.
However, we may be a little different. Out of all four properties, our 2 favorites are CSA and CTI. In fact, this April, we are headed back for trip #11 and doing a split between the two. We like them for similar and completely different reasons.
Out of the four, we think CTI and CSA have the most food options and best food variety. We like CTI because the beach is small and completely private and the resort is very compact and intimate. We like CSA because the beach is large and we can take long walks. We also think that hands-down, it has the calmest and most shallow water and deepest beach - mainly because it's the only resort that does not sit in a bay. At CTI (and CN and CSS) the odds of having choppy water are higher because of the bay, whereas at CSA it's pretty rare. It's also a personal choice - we like the vibe at CTI and CSA the best. However, we've only been to CSS and CN each once. All of the rest of our trips have been to CSA and CTI.
Others may choose one side over the other for the amenities or for the local flavor. For instance, Negril seems to be a more energetic city than Ocho Rios - although I would imagine that most guests never leave the property.
Here are some differences between the four:
CTI (Ocho Rios)- Completely private beach, yet small; Completely separate island (Tower Island) for AN sunbathing. Island open from 9a-5p pending good weather. Access via small boat that runs all day. AN sunbathers cannot be seen from the main beach. Textiled guests cannot access the island. No beach on island, just rocks. 6 restaurants (Bayside, 8 Rivers, Verandah, Patio, Pool Grill, Veggie Bar) including one that sits on the water; the most inclusions (Dunn's River, catamaran cruise). Only 3 buildings with rooms so the resort is very compact and intimate. Everything revolves around a central location. Recently underwent a $30 million renovation - new rooms, new decor, new pools, etc. Swim-up pool bar. Also includes room service from 7:30am - 9:30pm. All rooms have mini bars.
CSS (Ocho Rios) - the newest to the Couples resort, but not the newest built. It used to be a Grand Lido then Couples bought it. Also has a completely private beach. Completely separate beach for AN sunbathing - Sunset Beach, which opens up to textiled guests for the sunset.. Resort is very spread out vertically and built on cliffs. It's split into 3 different levels, lots of steps throughout. Lots of foliage and hidden spots. Does not offer a catamaran cruise. Only 3 restaurants (Palazzina, Casanova, beach grill) but room service 6:00am - 11:00pm. All rooms are suites with mini bars. Rooms are more hotel like as far as the decor.
CN (Negril)- Sits in Bloody Bay which it shares with 3 other resorts and public beach access. Separate section of main beach used for nude sunbathing, separated by a hedgeline. Individual buildings throughout the resort for the rooms. All on beach level. Somewhat spread out. Huge main pool with swim-up bar. 3 restaurants (Beach grill/Heliconia, Otaheite, Lychee). Rooms decorated in bright colors. 24 hour room service only in select room categories and it must be ordered a day in advance. All rooms have mini bars.
CSA (Negril)- Sits on 7 mile beach - shallowest water and deepest beach of all 4 because it's the only one not in a Bay. Separate buildings for rooms that are cabana like, dark wood and white linens. Resort is spread out along the beach but all on beach level. Many rooms have first floor access to the beach. Night Club. Some room categories do not have televisions. 6 restaurants (Palm, Patois, Lemon Grass, Feathers, Beach Grill, Sea Grape cafe). No nude sunbathing option. Huge sports and fitness complex across the street.
I am happy to share any of our pics or trip tips -
amy.welch@hotmail.com
Hope this helps!
Amy