You sound like me and my hubby when we were first determining where we would go.....we ended up at CSS. You will love the relaxing, intimate atmosphere while you can also make new friends at the swim up bars, events, etc. if you choose to. We also found a new love in the AN section. I am attaching a couple of pics from our room. We chose an oceanview with balcony and were in G block. There is an elevator and shuttle if the stairs get to be too much. You will love the room! It doesn't have a bathtub but it does have two complete sinks and countertops so each of you gets your own space. Hope this helps!