We stayed at CSA in a Garden Veranda. We always request the new side, 3rd floor corner and it is beautiful. At CSS we have had a one bedroom suite in F block and loved it. This past trip we booked a Penthouse, got E10, and absolutely hated it.
I find the rooms at CSA are smaller, they aren't suites, but the furnishings are much newer and fresher. The bathroom was 4 times as big as the one we had in the Penthouse believe it or not. When I sat on the sofa in our Penthouse, my butt nearly hit the ground it was so worn and I am not a big girl.
If I could have my Garden Verandah Suite moved to CSS I would be in heaven!
This will be our third trip to CSS and we have always stayed in a Penthouse Suite. Our first trip we were in the Steve McQueen Suite in D Block and our second trip we were in E Block. We loved E Block! It was close to the Balloon Bar and we had nice sloping stairs down to the main beach. I think you just need to be open to all the room options. You are in a Jamaican Paradise, the room as long as it is clean, and well tended and you are with the person you love, I think all the rooms are great. I have a soft spot for CSS!