I totally didn't have the nerve to do the SR....we picked CN for our honeymoon. We'll be there from Oct 12-22nd. We too are Canadian! (Ontario) Hope that you have a great time no matter where you end up!!
We did the SR the very 1st time and loved it. We didn't know the difference from one resort to the other so it was fine with us. You can't possibly go wrong the food & service is the best no matter which one your at. The only thing I would advise is if you want that beach that you can walk on for miles then definitely go to CSA. Our lst trip was to CSS and its still our favorite and seems to be the one most people get when doing SR.
My fiance and I did the SR and will not know whicg resort we will be staying at untill a week before, is that what you two did. We are leaving July 26 untill August 2. Kinda nervous, not knowing which one we are stying at, but also exciting at the same time!